Markey Mediation Services Logo


Dr. Mary Ann Markey

Florida Supreme Court Certified Family Mediator

⦿ Florida Supreme Court Mediator

⦿ Conflict Resolution Professional

⦿ Calm & Efficient

⦿ Remote Mediation Options

Holiday Gift-Giving, Expenses, and Financial Boundaries Across Two Households

  • Core Concept: The December holiday season often brings financial strain and competitive gift-giving between separated parents, leading to tension or breach of informal agreements.
  • Key Focus Areas:
    • Setting joint budgets for major child gifts and establishing rules around big-ticket items (e.g., electronics, phones, vehicles).
    • Mediating financial obligations, extra-curricular costs, and seasonal child support adjustments before entering the new tax year.
    • Preventing “gift competition” and keeping the focus on emotional presence rather than material comparison.

The December holiday season often brings an escalation in emotional and financial strain, and can result in competitive gift-giving between the separated parents which leads to intra-family tension and even the breach of informal agreements. The motivation underlying the tendency toward competitive gift-giving has been identified as arising from feelings of guilt due to the divorce, a sense of revenge toward the other parent, unconsciously feeling they have to “buy” the affection of the child(ren), needing external approval from others for their actions and generosity, associating their worth with a demonstration of wealth and the ability to purchase and shower their child(ren) with the expensive gifts, etc. 

Seeing joint budgets to enable both parents to contribute toward major gifts for their child(ren) often helps to promote a collaborative rather than a competitive mindset between the parents, and it does demonstrate a unified front regarding their decision-making efforts. Certain big-tickets items have a level of responsibility attached to them and should be age-appropriate. For example, with the purchase of a vehicle as a gift, there are additional expenses attached to that item, for example, insurance, gas, and maintenance where the parents have to decide who pays for what or are they splitting each of the expenses equally? Electronics can bring along their own conundrum of rules pertaining to supervision of access, websites, screen time, social media, etc. So, this purchase is not just about the purchase price but other concerns that accompany that purchase. What happens if one of those big-ticket items becomes lost or damaged? Who bears that burden or is it divided equally between the parents?

Holiday gifts can include extra-curricular activities, sports equipment, taking classes online or in-person, transportation to and from the location or venue, etc. Is this being paid for by one parent or equally divided between both parents. What happens if one parent does not approve of the gifted sport equipment, activity, class, etc.? Do they not contribute to the expense or participate in the transportation back-and-forth? How is that dispute going to be resolved after-the-fact? This is a situation where an early discussion could have prevented not only conflict between the parents but also potential disappointment on the part of the child(ren).

The end of the year requires the mediation of financial obligations, the review of child overnight visitations and support adjustments, a discussion of income tax dependent declarations, etc. Financial affidavits may be impacted by changes in employment, job losses, job promotions, raises, bonuses, relocation for work, return to college, professional training, traveling for work, etc. While income tax returns are not officially due until mid-April, it is wise for parents to begin organizing their finances so that any necessary post-decree modifications can be made as early as possible in the New Year.

#DrMaryAnnMarkey #FloridaSupremeCourtCertifiedFamilyMediator #FloridaFamilyMediator #FamilyMediatorInFlorida

Why should you work with Dr. Markey?

Decades of Proven Expertise: With extensive experience as a Conflict Resolution Professional and Mediator, Dr. Markey brings a deep, institutional understanding of family mediation and complex dispute resolution to every case.

Published Thought Leadership: As a prolific author and researcher in conflict resolution, she utilizes evidence-based strategies and modern methodologies to navigate even the most difficult emotional and legal deadlocks.

Commitment to Lasting Results: Dr. Markey focuses on more than just a temporary fix; she specializes in creating sustainable, equitable agreements that provide all parties with the clarity and confidence needed to move forward.

Understanding Family Mediation

  • Less Stress and Lower Cost: Mediation is generally a more streamlined process and less expensive than traditional litigation. By avoiding a lengthy legal battle, families can reduce the financial burden and the emotional toll on themselves and their children.

  • A Guided Conversation: It is a structured process where a neutral third party helps family members talk through their differences in a safe environment rather than fighting it out in a courtroom.

  • You Keep the Control: Unlike a trial where a judge makes the final decisions, mediation gives you the power to create your own solutions. No agreement is reached unless everyone involved signs off on it.

  • Private and Confidential: Court cases are public record, but mediation happens behind closed doors. Most of what is discussed is private, allowing for honest conversation without the details becoming part of a public file.

  • Focus on the Future: While legal battles often dwell on past mistakes, mediation focuses on practical solutions for the future – specifically regarding co-parenting schedules, asset division, and long-term stability.

Remote Comfort with Flexible Options

Sessions are held virtually, allowing you to participate from the privacy of your own space. For added comfort, “shuttle” mediation is available as an option – this allows Dr. Markey to meet with each party individually in private digital rooms to reduce tension and facilitate progress without direct confrontation.